Apples on noses

Speaking a second language can change everything from problem-solving skills to personality. It is almost as if you are two people, says Catherine de Lange.

 

“Mon espirit paratage — My two minds”, appeared in the New Scientist of May 5th, 2012. Ms. de Lange compared monolingual and bilingual children. The Washington Post included her article online.

THE WASHINGTON POST: EDUCATORS ONCE OPPOSED RAISING BILINGUAL CHILDREN. EXPERTS NOW SAY IT’S BENEFICIAL

 

Ms. de Lange tested children on SYNTAX, that is, the way to put words together, to phrase own talk or writing.

 

She wrote:
Both monolinguals and bilinguals could see the mistake in phrases such as “apples growed on trees”, but differences arose when they considered nonsensical sentences such as “apples grow on noses”. The monolinguals, flummoxed by the silliness of the phrase, incorrectly reported an error, whereas the bilinguals gave the right answer.

 

Children get to hear or read fairy tales. Whether the kid speaks one or more languages, it is only important that he or she comprehends the words: there was a fairy land, a long time ago, where apples grew on noses.

 

Most probably, Ms. de Lange misconstrued her tasks DEICTICALLY. The children did not know what noses the talk was about, and if to focus on syntax or PRAGMATICS, that is, on talk in context.

 

Let us consider two examples of deictically misconstrued questions.

 

Picture 1. Is there a real nose in the picture?

COLLAGE: SCULPTURE, BOAT, AND AIRCRAFT NOSES

Picture 2. Could we have an apple square?

PINE APPLE, APPLE, AND APPLE CORNER ROAD SIGN

 

Let us think what the world would have to be, should Ms. de Lange have been right. She wrote she spoke English and French.

 

Monolingual speakers of French would carry shields instead of umbrellas, for “heavy rain”. They would belong with the people to get “flummoxed” with figures of speech, and it rains halberds in French, when it rains cats and dogs in English (in which latter case we would have to think monolingual English people cannot keep appointments, staying home).

 

LAROUSSE ONLINE, IL TOMBE HALLEBARDES, IT’S RAINING CATS AND DOGS

 

We would have to dread multilingual medics. They would belong with the people who do not care what words mean literally. With them, a cardiac case might serve a game of opinion, as well.

 

AMERICAN HERITAGE DICTIONARY, CHANGES OF HEART

 

We may yet choose to think what the world is really. Both English and French have spoken and written forms.

 

What we write as bread in English is un pain, in French. What we write as pain in English, is nothing even potentially pleasant, whatever the language.

 

LAROUSSE ONLINE: “UN PAIN” IN FRENCH IS “BREAD” IN ENGLISH

 

A BOY EATING BREAD, PUBLIC DOMAIN PICTURES

 

A BOY EATING BREAD, PHOTO CREDIT: PUBLIC DOMAIN PICTURES

 

Speakers of English and French languages have had much contact, in history as well. It must be, in this real world, that human languages rely on semantics, that is, word sense.

 

Word form alone is not sufficient to make the psychological reality of language. Otherwise, either the French or the English (or both) would have changed their words.

 

Ms. de Lange should not have inferred on the children’s mental reality, from an experiment to disregard deictics and word sense. For and idea to exercise solely syntax, feel welcome to the Grammar Web Log,
BUTTON, GRAMMAR WEB LOG: SEE THE COLOR CODE AND VIRTUAL WORDS

 

Generally, experimentation on children raises ethical concerns, and honestly, for language acquisition, there is no need to experiment: it is enough to listen and talk.

 

A very serious ethical concern comes with Ms. de Lange reporting infant brain scans for experimental purposes. There is no way to obtain informed consent from an infant.

*****

LINK: READ THIS IN A SLAVIC LANGUAGE, POLISH

Advertisements

Feel welcome to comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s